Grilled NY Strip Steak Recipe With Compound Butter

If you’re not having grilled NY strip steak for dinner tonight, you’re missing out. This delicious recipe, complete with how to make compound butter, is everything you’ve been waiting for and then some.

Grilled NY Strip Steak Recipe With Compound Butter

Compound Butter Recipe

Making your own compound butter is a 2-minute process that will up your game significantly. These are the ingredients you are going to need:

  • Butter, 1/4 C
  • Sage, 1 tsp
  • Chives, 1 tsp
  • Parsley, 1 tsp
  • Thyme, 1 tsp
  • Minced Garlic, 1 clove
  • Sea salt & black pepper

Put all the ingredients in a large enough bowl. Make sure you let the butter sit at room temperature for a couple of minutes beforehand to soften. Mix everything well until even.

Scoop the compound butter out of the bowl, and wrap it in saran wrap. Chill in the fridge for 1-2 hours.

Grilling NY Strip Steaks

While your grill is coming up to temp, take a moment to season the NY strip steaks. Use freshly ground black pepper, and either sea or Kosher salt – larger flakes will add to the texture later on. Make sure you don’t forget to season the fat cap.

Let the steaks sit at room temperature for 10 minutes, so the meat can sweat through the rub.

Once the pit is sitting at around 225º-230ºF, place the steaks on the heat and close the lid. Cook to an internal temperature of 125ºF.

The Final Sear

Let the steaks cool down for only a few minutes. Then put them back on the pit, this time directly over your heat source. Sear each side for 45 seconds before flipping. Repeat so each side is seared twice.

Your grilled NY strip steak is ready! Serve with some compound butter, and enjoy!

More Recipes

Exclusive Pitmaster Gear

Grilled NY Strip Steak
King of the Grill Trucker Cap Snapback | Grilling Hat for Dad
Grilled NY Strip Steak
Heat Resistant Silicone Gloves for BBQ